This review is part of a sequence of reviews of war movies that have Christmas as their main theme. There are many war movies in which a part takes place during Christmas or in which it is evoked but that are not the ones I’d like to focus on. I want to focus on those that really center on it.
The first one I’m reviewing is, as you can see, Silent Night, A Midnight Clear, Joyeux Noël and maybe one or two older ones will follow.
The TV drama Silent Night is based on true facts. It is set on Christmas Eve 1944, just after the Battle of the Bulge. A mother and her young son are seeking refuge in the family’s hunting lodge in the middle of the Ardennes Forest. They walk through the war-torn woods, approach the front line and pass dead bodies, troops of soldiers and tanks.
They have just arrived at the lodge when two American soldiers arrive, carrying one of their wounded. The woman lets them stay reluctantly but makes them leave their weapons in front of the house. Elisabeth Vincken (Linda Hamilton) is not what you would call a patriot. She has lost her eldest son at Stalingrad, her husband is probably dead as well and the youngest, Fritz, would like to join the Hitler Youth which she wants to prevent at all costs.
While they are looking after the badly wounded soldier, a group of three German soldiers arrives at the hut and the encounter almost ends in mutual shooting. Elisabeth is a very strong woman, very determined and persuasive. After some initial discussions and negotiations they agree to leave their weapons behind, enter the house and spend the night there in peace.
I don’t think that anyone present during this Christmas dinner was likely to ever forget it. It would certainly be the most memorable Christmas of their lives. They sit around the table, share their food and stories, talk about the way in which this and the former war affected them. Still, tensions do not subside completely. The German lieutenant has a particularly hard time to stay peaceful. He is bitter and aggressive, however, after a moment of escalation, he starts to see how absurd this all is and gives in as well. There is a final test that will show if these men have truly become friends in one evening. And if so, will they stay friends later on?
One thing, as often, that truly bothered me were the bad accents. Americans speaking German with heavy American accents and then fake English accents. But cheer up, I have been assured that it doesn’t bother you if you don’t speak German.
The movie has a few very sentimental moments but it is overall not bad at all, no it is quite a pleasant movie that achieves to capture the spirit of Christmas. Recommended Sunday afternoon viewing with loads of snow, drama and some genuinely heartfelt moments.
I also included Silent Night in my update Children in War Movies List.
[…] Silent Night (2002, USA): WWII, Germany (see my post on Silent Night) […]
Good post. Sounds similar to Midnight Clear. I’ll put it on my list.
A Midnight Clear is certainly better. Will have to re-watch to be sure. Hopefully next week.
[…] I have been complaining about the use of languages in Silent Night, I might add here that this is flawless in this movie. The German soldiers are played by German […]
Based on true accounts, was there a book?, would like to read the story this was based on
I didn’t find a book title. I looked on IMDB but it only states the writer of the scenario, Roger Aylward.
Loved this movie. Well done. All comes down to,we’re all humans. Everybody has a story. Friendship comes out of a horrible situation and respect for a woman and her son.
I agree. My review did maybe not show it enough but I truly liked it. It’s one of my favorite Christmas movies and since it’s a true story, it’s even better.