At the beginning of Ken Loach’s movie Land and Freedom, we see a young woman sorting out the things her late grandfather has left behind. She finds a suitcase full of black and white photos, newspaper articles and letters that show her a hidden part in her grandfather’s life. Little had she known that he had fought in the Spanish Civil War and loved a Spanish woman.
In 1936 David Carr (Ian Hart) is an unemployed miner and member of the British Communist Party. When someone from the Spanish Communist Party shows up and tells them about the Civil War in Spain in which the people fight against General Franco’s Army and the rich landowners, David spontaneously decides to go to Spain and fight for the rights of the people.
On his train journey he meets people from the Spanish militia, part of the POUM, a communist group that fights independently of the International Stalinist Brigades. He has no particular place to be and decides to join them. The people in the little group he is fighting with are all idealists. They come from all over the world, the US, Germany, Italy, Ireland, the UK. They want to fight for the rights of the peasants and the poor and not join the Stalinist Brigades which they consider to be corrupt and only interested in their own cause.
David who at first seems to think he is living some kind of adventure, soon faces the harsh reality. Not only is the fighting often heavy and there are casualties but they are badly trained and equipped and the Stalinists keep the weapons from them. When one of those faulty guns explodes, David is injured and sent to the hospital. Blanca, one of the group visits him in Barcelona, after he has come out of the hospital. They spend a night together but she leaves disgusted when she finds out that David has decided to join the Stalinists.
David will regret his decision soon enough and return to his old POUM group. The movie ends tragically and on a note of utter disillusionment.
Land and Freedom was absolutely not what I had expected and I assume that is exactly what Ken Loach was aiming for. We all have our ideas about the Spanish Civil War, some very romantic ones mostly. We know that Hemingway fought in Spain and so many other writers, painters… It seemed to have been one of the very rare wars with a justified cause to fight for. Ken Loach destroys all our romantic ideas and that is why the movie is good and annoying at the same time. He tries to show how it must have been. The fights and differences within the Communist Party and their subgroups, the endless talking and theorizations. The middle part of the movie is one long annoying and boring conversation and dispute about collectivism.
An aspect I wasn’t familiar with is the fact that women were only allowed to fight alongside the men at the beginning of the war. Later it was decided that they had to do “womanly” things like cooking or being nurses. I thought that women fought all through this war. Another shattered illusion.
Loach has earned a lot of praise and got also a lot of scolding for this movie. Some think that finally someone told it as it was, others think he dirtied the memory of the Spanish Civil War.
I am a fan of Ken Loach‘s movies, he has done quite a few that I liked a lot, although I wouldn’t go as far as saying that I liked Land and Freedom, I must say, I appreciated it. I felt somewhat stupid for having to realize that my idea of the Spanish Civil War had maybe been a tad too romantic as well.
Unfortunately there was no trailer of Land and Freedom, only the first part of the movie.
The shift in the roles of women occurred when the POUM (a marxist-Communist union allied with FAI/CNT anarchist groups) came under Stalinist control. That’s when they were sent back to the kitchen duties.
Have you seen Libertarias? It takes a look at the Spanish civil war through the lives of three Mujeres Libres. Over 30,000 female anarchists were Mujeres Libres. Many fought and died in the civil war.
Thanks so much for the comment, I didn’t know the movie, will have to track it down. Thanks. I think my knowledge of the Spanish Civil War was too Hemingway influenced. Too idealized.
I’m taking a guess that you’d really like Libertarias. It’ll be a good fit for the blog.
Thanks, I’ll try to find it although it seems impossible.
I am more interested in Libertarias. I do not find the Spanish Civil War compelling and have not read anything on it.
But Libertarias is about the Spanish Civil War.
I know, that’s why I might watch it and check Spanish Civil War movie off my bucket list.
Ah, that’s what you meant.
Can anyone tell me what the function and treatment of David’s great daughter Kim is?
She finds photos, letters and newspaper articles of David after his death and discovers aspects of a life and love she didn’t know anything about. I hope this answers the question.