101 War Movies You Must See Before You Die (2009) is a very nicely done reference book, part of a whole series of 101 or 1001 movies you must see before you die books. Picture books actually.
It’s ordered chronologically and contains colour photographs of the movie posters, naming of Cast & Crew, followed by a detailed description of the movie and some words on its importance. Additionally there is a colour photo of a scene depicting one or the other crucial moment of the movie with its description.
It is very nice to look at especially for those enthusiastic about movie posters. The entries are not very critical but this seems only normal since the aim was to choose 101 must-see movies so one can safely assume the authors rated them all as outstanding.
From a purist’s point of view I think that the editors chose to include a lot of movies that are normally part of subgenres that the die-hard war movie fan would exclude. They therefore added movies like Schindler’s List (1993) that you could rather call a wartime movie or Last of The Mohicans (1992)which is more of a War/Action Romance film.
Looking at their choices I think one of their main criteria was the esthetics of a movie and to a certain extent it’s blockbuster value, meaning how much of a story beyond the pure historical facts was told (totally contrary to Gary Freitas who would choose accuracy and history over story). This is why Platoon was included but neither Hamburger Hill (1987) nor 84 Charlie MoPic (1989) that are on many levels better.
Since I do not tend to be as strict as many, and would maybe even include Casablanca (1942) (which they didn’t include) I don’t mind their approach.
But what really does it for me are the pictures. I just love those posters. They are an art form in their own right.
I just got the book and agree with you. Neat book, but not definitive. Nice addition to my collection. My favorite is “Video Hound’s War Movies”.
The problem with these lists is that they are hardly ever definitive. I have a few books here, one of the best is German however so i did not wan’t to recommend it. At present I would not be capable of making a 100 list myself yet. And there is always the aspect that we like something well knowing it is not a 100% good. At least I do. Thanks for the book suggestion, will have to see if I find it.
The reason why I choose Military History Magazine’s Top 100 is because it was compiled by a panel of experts with a variety of expertise. Of course, this means there are some movies like “Ben Hur” that I will violently disagree with, but that will be fun and I will be able to substitute better movies.
I still haven’t seen the list yet although I found a link that incorporated it. I am afraid it will leave out some of the movies I consider to be the best to be as they are European. But maybe not. Every list will always leave out something we like. I realised lately, whenreading varous lists that Enemy at the Gates gets left out often. I think I know why and will do a post on it.